Dr Win Huang’s Clinical Reflections | As Medicine Becomes More Specialised, Are We Dividing the Patient Too?
Dr Win Huang’s Clinical Reflections | As Medicine Becomes More Specialised, Are We Dividing the Patient Too?
By Dr Win Huang, PhD (Chinese Medicine & Acupuncture)
A 53-year-old man came to my clinic today.
He works in IT and spends long hours sitting in front of a computer. Over the past few months, his main concern has been poor sleep. He wakes frequently during the night and almost always wakes at around 5:30 am, finding it difficult to fall asleep again. During the day, he feels noticeably tired and lacks energy.
He also feels unusually cold. In the office, when everyone else is comfortable with the temperature, he often feels cold and needs to wear more clothing. His hands and feet also become cold easily.
Because of his interrupted sleep and early waking, his GP was considering a referral to a sleep or neurology-related specialist. His fatigue and sensitivity to cold also raised the need for further investigations into thyroid function, metabolism and possible endocrine problems.
However, as I continued asking questions, I discovered another group of symptoms.
He frequently experiences aching and discomfort in his right shoulder and arm, sometimes accompanied by numbness in his fingers. He also has pain in the right side of his chest and upper back. These symptoms become more noticeable after prolonged computer or mouse use, or after driving. His physiotherapist suspected a possible neck, shoulder or nerve-related problem and recommended further assessment by an orthopaedic or other relevant specialist.
In this way, one person’s problems were naturally divided into several areas. Sleep disturbance belonged to sleep medicine or neurology. Fatigue and cold sensitivity belonged to endocrinology. Shoulder and arm pain, chest and back discomfort, and finger numbness belonged to orthopaedics, neurology or musculoskeletal medicine.
The patient himself was becoming increasingly confused about what was happening to his body.
Specialisation Is Necessary, but We Should Not Divide the Person
Modern medicine has become increasingly specialised, and this is a necessary part of medical development. Specialisation allows doctors to develop deeper knowledge and greater expertise in particular areas. There is nothing wrong with that.
The question is whether, as medicine becomes more specialised, we gradually focus only on which department a symptom belongs to and forget that all these symptoms are occurring in the same person.
Patients have also learned to understand their bodies according to medical specialties. When seeing an orthopaedic specialist, they may talk only about shoulder pain and finger numbness. When seeing an endocrinologist, they focus on fatigue and feeling cold. When seeing a sleep specialist, they describe their insomnia.
As a result, the same person can gradually become several different patients in different consulting rooms.
If I Had Only Asked About His Sleep, I Would Have Missed the Rest
The main reason this patient came to see me was also his poor sleep. If I had focused only on his sleeping difficulties, I might have ended up seeing him simply as a patient with insomnia.
But when I continued asking about his work, fatigue, cold sensitivity, shoulder and back pain, chest discomfort and upper-limb symptoms, a more complete clinical picture began to emerge.
He spends long hours working at a computer, and examination revealed considerable muscle tension and tenderness around his neck, shoulders and upper back. He also enjoys going to the gym and did not appear physically weak. His tongue and pulse findings did not strongly suggest a typical deficiency pattern.
From a Chinese medicine perspective, I therefore did not simply classify his condition as Yang deficiency or Yin deficiency. Instead, I was more inclined to consider Qi stagnation and impaired Qi movement.
Within Chinese medicine theory, impaired Qi movement may affect sleep, energy and the circulation of Qi and Blood. It may also be associated with distending discomfort, pain and numbness around the chest, back, shoulders and arms.
When the symptoms that had been separated into different specialties were brought back together within the same person, another way of understanding his condition became possible.
A Whole-Person Approach Is Not Unique to Chinese Medicine
Modern medicine can also examine possible connections between these symptoms.
Prolonged computer work and sitting may place sustained mechanical demands on the muscles of the neck, shoulders, chest and upper back. Pain and physical tension may disturb sleep, while persistent poor sleep can increase fatigue, influence pain sensitivity and affect general physical wellbeing.
In other words, even without using the Chinese medicine concept of Qi stagnation, we do not necessarily have to regard all these symptoms as completely unrelated conditions.
Modern medicine also has its own whole-person approaches. General practice, rehabilitation medicine, pain medicine and the biopsychosocial model all recognise the importance of considering the patient’s work, lifestyle, physical function, psychological state and wider circumstances rather than focusing only on one organ or symptom.
The real question is:
As medicine becomes increasingly specialised, is someone still willing to bring all this separated information back together and look at the person as a whole?
The Person Must Remain at the Centre of Clinical Care
A whole-person approach does not mean that every symptom must have one single cause. When thyroid, cardiovascular, neurological or other conditions need to be investigated, those investigations should still be carried out.
But before we continue dividing a patient among different specialties, we should ask one more question: Could these symptoms be connected?
Specialised medicine helps us look more deeply. A whole-person approach reminds us not to look too narrowly.
The human body is not a collection of unrelated parts. Sleep, emotions, pain, muscle tension, working habits and physical activity can all influence one another. When a patient experiences several symptoms, it does not necessarily mean that they have several completely independent problems.
Specialisation is necessary for the development of medicine, but it should never divide the person.
Regardless of which medical system or specialty we practise, the person in front of us is always a whole human being.
Revised: 18 November 2026
中文微信:nzacupunctureclinic
Leave a reply